On March 15, 2024, at approximately 6:40 PM, Tyler Reeves (age 25, unemployed) entered a Circle K convenience store at 3201 W. Camelback Road, Phoenix, Arizona. Store surveillance cameras recorded Reeves selecting items from shelves — including two energy drinks ($7.98), a phone charger ($19.99), beef jerky packs ($24.97), and assorted snacks ($74.04) — and placing them inside his unzipped jacket over approximately 3 minutes. At 6:44 PM, Reeves walked toward the exit. Store clerk Maria Dominguez called out to him from behind the register. Reeves stopped at the door, said "Oh, I forgot — my bad," then attempted to leave. Dominguez pressed the silent alarm; Reeves was detained by an off-duty security guard in the parking lot 30 seconds later. Total merchandise value: $126.98. Under Arizona Revised Statutes §13-1802, theft of property valued between $100 and $1,000 is a Class 1 misdemeanor (up to 6 months jail). Reeves claims he received a phone call while shopping that distracted him and he "simply forgot" to pay. His phone records show a 47-second incoming call at 6:41 PM.
In-store surveillance footage (3 cameras, continuous)
Camera 1 (snack aisle): Shows Reeves at 6:40:22 PM selecting beef jerky and energy drinks. He holds items briefly, looks around, then slides them into his unzipped jacket. Camera 2 (electronics/accessories aisle): At 6:41:55 PM Reeves picks up a phone charger, appears to examine it, places it inside his jacket. He is visibly holding his phone to his ear during this action. Camera 3 (front register/exit): At 6:44:01 PM Reeves walks toward the exit without approaching the register. Clerk Dominguez looks up and calls out. Reeves stops at the door (6:44:04), turns partially, says something, then pushes the door open. He is detained in the parking lot at 6:44:38. Prosecution: concealment inside jacket (not hand/basket) over 3+ minutes shows deliberate hiding, not absent-mindedness. Defense: Reeves was on the phone during key moments and stopped voluntarily when addressed.
Phone records (AT&T call log, subpoenaed)
Incoming call from contact "Mom" at 6:41:12 PM, duration 47 seconds (ended 6:41:59 PM). No other calls during the 6:40–6:45 window. Defense argues: the call began while Reeves was mid-shopping, creating a distraction that explains why he placed items in his jacket (phone in one hand, no free hand for carrying). Prosecution argues: the call ended at 6:41:59 — Reeves continued placing items in his jacket for another 2+ minutes after the call ended (charger concealed at 6:41:55 is during the call, but no further call covers 6:42–6:44 when he walked past the register and toward the exit).
Recovered merchandise inventory
Items recovered from Reeves's jacket in the parking lot: Monster Energy (×2, $3.99 each), Slim Jim beef jerky (×3, $8.32 each), Jack Link's Original (×1, $8.49 extra-large bag), Phone charger USB-C (×1, $19.99), assorted candy bars (×4, total $11.96), bag of trail mix (×1, $5.49). Total: $126.98. All items had store price tags intact. No basket or shopping bag was used. Defense notes: Reeves had his wallet in his back pocket with a debit card showing a $1,400 balance — he had the means to pay.
Store clerk incident report and silent alarm log
Maria Dominguez (clerk on duty) filed an incident report at 7:05 PM: "Customer placed items in jacket while shopping. Did not approach register. I said 'Sir, do you need to check out?' He stopped, said 'Oh my bad, I forgot,' then tried to leave anyway. I hit the alarm button." Silent alarm triggered at 6:44:06 PM (2 seconds after Reeves stopped). Key dispute: Dominguez says Reeves "tried to leave anyway" after acknowledging her; Reeves says he was "about to come back to the register" when the security guard grabbed him.
Arizona statutory presumption (ARS §13-1805)
Arizona Revised Statutes §13-1805(A): "A person who knowingly conceals upon himself or another person unpurchased merchandise of any mercantile establishment while still on the premises of such establishment shall be presumed to have the necessary culpable mental state..." This statutory presumption of intent is rebuttable — but the defense must present evidence sufficient to overcome it. Defense argues: the phone call, voluntary stop, wallet with funds, and "I forgot" statement collectively rebut the presumption. Prosecution argues: concealment over 3 minutes, walking past the register without hesitation, and attempting to exit even after being addressed satisfy the statute.
Maria Dominguez (Circle K clerk, prosecution witness)
Store clerk on duty at the time of the incident; has worked at this Circle K for 2 years; trained in loss prevention protocols
I noticed him putting things in his jacket from the camera monitor behind the counter. I watched for a minute to be sure. When he walked toward the door without coming to my register, I called out to him. He stopped, looked at me, said "Oh, I forgot, my bad" — but then he pushed the door open and kept going. If he really forgot, why didn't he come back to the register? He was leaving. I hit the alarm.
Officer James Hadley (arresting officer, prosecution witness)
Phoenix PD patrol officer who responded to the silent alarm; 4 years on the force
I arrived at the scene at 6:51 PM. The off-duty security guard had Reeves seated on the curb. Reeves was cooperative and calm. He immediately said "I was going to pay — I just forgot. Check my wallet." I recovered the merchandise from his jacket. He had a wallet with a debit card. I read him his rights and transported him to the precinct. In my experience, people who genuinely forget to pay don't conceal items inside their clothing — they carry them openly.
Tyler Reeves (defendant, defense witness)
The defendant; age 25; unemployed for 3 months following a layoff from a warehouse job; no prior criminal record
I went in to grab some stuff. My mom called while I was shopping and I was talking to her about a job interview I have next week. I didn't have a basket so I just stuck things in my jacket to free up my hand for the phone. When the lady called out, I stopped — I wasn't trying to run. I said I forgot. Then this security guy grabbed me before I could even turn around. I had $1,400 in my account — why would I steal $127 worth of snacks?
Convenience Store Shoplifting — Phoenix, AZ
Choose a role to start
